Advantages & Disadvantages of Using Flat Fee Recruiters for Recruiting Staff

A comprehensive guide to using flat fee recruiters for recruiting staff is available.

Advantages of Using a Flat Fee Recruiter

• Cost-effectiveness: Flat fee recruiters charge a fixed price for their services, often significantly lower than the fees charged by traditional recruiters or multiple job sites.
• Simplified budgeting: Costs are predictable and not variable based on the position’s salary.
• Bulk discounts: Employers looking to fill multiple positions may benefit from discounts, making large-scale recruitment drives more economical.
• No commission: Unlike traditional recruitment agencies, flat fee recruiters don’t take a commission, which can be a considerable saving, especially for higher-salary roles.
• Risk reduction: The low upfront cost reduces financial risk if no one is hired.
• Industry-wide recruitment: Because they advertise across a wide range of job sites, flat fee recruiters are often equipped to handle recruitment across various industries, sectors and levels of seniority.
• Application filtering: Many flat fee recruiters provide application filtering or screening to save employers from sifting through completely irrelevant CVs.
• Customer support: Good flat fee recruiters offer solid customer support to guide employers through recruitment. 
• Access to specialised boards: Flat fee recruiters can often negotiate access to specialist job sites if required (although I normally recommend trying the sites they include in a standard package first before going to any more expense.
• Quick turnaround: Flat fee recruitment services attract applications quickly, allowing for a faster recruitment process. This speed is invaluable for urgent job vacancies.
• Time-saving: The recruiter handles the administrative burden of posting job adverts and initial CV filtering, saving the employer time.
• Additional services: Employers can use additional recruitment services like CV database searches, shortlisting, or interview arrangement services.
• Non-exclusive arrangements: Generally, employers are not locked into exclusive arrangements with flat fee recruiters, allowing them to explore other avenues if desired.
• No long-term commitment: Using a flat fee recruiter doesn’t usually require a long-term contractual commitment, offering businesses flexibility.
• Scalability: Flat fee recruitment is scalable; employers can advertise one or multiple job vacancies without a substantial increase in cost.

‍

Disadvantages of Using a Flat Fee Recruiter

• Lack of personalisation: Flat fee recruiters will not provide the personalised service and in-depth candidate assessment that traditional recruitment agencies and headhunters offer.
• No guarantee of success: They generally do not guarantee a successful placement; if you don’t hire, the advertising cost is not refunded.
• Quantity over quality: There might be a focus on the number of applicants rather than the quality, which can lead to an overwhelming number of applications to sort through.
• Hidden costs: Some flat fee recruiters may have additional costs for essential services, which aren’t always apparent upfront.
• Time investment: Employers may need to invest more time in shortlisting applicants.‍
• Lack of post-hire support: Unlike traditional recruiters, flat fee services typically do not provide post-placement support or guarantees if the candidate does not work out.